Fresh dough made daily.

MaMaMias will be temporarily closed until further notice due to a plaza fire. We suffered major smoke damage and are currently going through an extensive restoration. Please check our website or our Facebook page for updates. We look forward to reopening soon.

Please note that we DO NOT accept $50 or $100 bills for dine in, carry out or delivery.


Just like Mama used to make.



We use 100% REAL mozzarella cheese.

Call to order 


 Eat in or carry out.

We deliver!

Including all Peach Street and Millcreek Mall hotels

Credit or debit card required for ALL hotel deliveries.   NO EXCEPTIONS

Minimum food order of $15.00 to all hotels, excludes pop and snacks.          NO EXCEPTIONS

Drivers DO NOT accept $50 or $100 bills.

Delivery fee applies to all deliveries.

Delivery unavailable